top of page
  • Writer's pictureHardcover Hearts

Right book, wrong format?


I just finished this book, These Ghosts Are Family by Maisy Card, and I wonder if I made a mistake. Did I pick the wrong format for this book?


Whenever I read a book with colloquial dialect or another form of dialogue that would be enhanced by audio format, I will seek that out from my public library. I did that with These Ghosts Are Family.


The first time I employed this technique, was after hitting a wall with Marlon James' A Brief History of Seven Killings, and it was a game changer. The characters stood out more clearly, and the richness of the language, with its rhythms and unfamiliar pronunciations, was a joy to hear. I was able to enter that world that I had previously been struggling with, and losing, to be honest.


The narration of These Ghosts Are Family was fantastic, done by Karl O'Brien Williams, who did a remarkable job with the timbre of his voice, the differentiation of the varied characters and the performance overall. So the problem wasn't with that. Maybe there are some books that structurally aren't best experienced via different formats?


I was chatting with my dear friend, Leo, about this, specifically regarding his renewed dislike of his Kindle. He said something that resonated with me- that it's "all the same" when you read a book with a kindle. When you close it, you don't see the cover. You can't peek ahead to see how many more pages to the beginning of the next chapter. You can't feel the texture of the pages, or smell the book, and all that adds up to an impersonal reading experience. That conversation made me start to think about formats more deeply.


So when it came to my thinking about how I would rate this book, I couldn't ignore the fact that I think the audio format didn't let me engage with this book in the best way. This book is complex. The structure is intricate, but you don't know that going into the book, especially if you go into a book like I do, without knowing much about it. As an example, there is a diagram of the family tree that precedes the story as the chapters and sections bounce forward and backward in time. It makes engaging with the material challenging when it is read to you without the visual grounding of that family tree or chapter anchors.


The writing was very solid. The characters were rich and the sections that made up a branch or part of the story were wonderful. A challenge with these types of multiple character stories is that some of the arcs naturally resonate more deeply than others do. That did happen for me with this book, but it was saved by flipping into another or a new storyline fairly quickly. We didn't overstay our welcome in any one character's section- and that was both good and bad.


The book opens with an old man, Abel, who has arranged for a new homecare provider to be assigned. He has asked for a specific woman- not because of her skills as a nurse, but because he is her father and by arranging this meeting, he will be returning from the dead. He has a secret that he doesn't want to be burdened by anymore and that is that when he was on a trip for his work decades earlier, when this now middle aged woman was a small child, his travel companion/friend was killed in an accident and his name was mistakenly attributed to the dead man. Abel saw an opportunity in the moment to escape his life and reinvent himself, so he took it.


It was the kind of opening to a book that I love- a surprising set up. I was immediately hooked. I asked myself if this was a male version of Patsy by Nicole Dennis-Benn, with a Jamaican father character who abandons his family for a new life abroad? I was so impressed by that book and was excited to see if this would be the case. The parallels were strong, but this book branched out along that family tree quickly, and we didn't spend as much of a focus on that character for my theory to pan out.


The sections of These Ghosts Are Family were very well told, the characters interesting and dynamic, and the settings rich. The themes of regret and loss appeared in the form of ghosts who pepper the stories in interesting ways. The impacts of slavery on this family is never that far removed, regardless of the time and distance from the last enslaved member of their lineage. It's a powerful and inventive novel.


Speaking of ghosts, I think I will be haunted by the question that nags at me- would I have liked the book more, or connected with it more deeply if I had read and not listened to the audiobook edition? As such, it was fine, but I suspect that there were more layers to enjoy that I missed in the listening.



12 Comments


holt3129
Feb 19, 2021

I agree wholeheartedly that format can make or break a book. I listen to a lot of audio books from the library when I have activities to engage in and am not able to sit and read. I recently listened to over 40 hours of Red Comet. Mesmerizing! I couldn’t stop. And, yet, there are many books I’ve read in the physical format previously and years later tried the audio format, like Maya Angelou’s. The breadth and intensity of feeling was not there. Readers make a tremendous difference too. Linda Lavin reading Ruth Bader Ginsberg’s In My Own Words was awful so I returned to my favorite, like Leo, of the physical format. There’s nothing like a real book in…

Like
Hardcover Hearts
Hardcover Hearts
Feb 19, 2021
Replying to

Well, hello Leslie! Nice to meet you. And unfortunately I don’t know a lot about this platform to advise how to fix it. But the good news is that I have so few followers that I’m sure to remember! 😉

Like

Sarah Hepworth
Sarah Hepworth
Feb 18, 2021

I've had similar and also the reverse - did I get more from this book more because the audio enhanced the experience. Would I have rated it as highly if I had read the print/ebook version. I'm happy accessing books in different formats. To be honest my decision on which format usually comes down to cost and availability but perhaps I should also be thinking more about which would be the best experience option. Interesting topic which has had me thinking over the past couple of days.

Like
Hardcover Hearts
Hardcover Hearts
Feb 19, 2021
Replying to

Yes- availability is huge for me because I can’t afford to buy all the books I read or listen to, so finding a public library edition is a huge plus. That’s a great point.

Like

judyjudyb
Feb 18, 2021

Format definitely matters, especially when choosing between print and audio. I have become more thoughtful about choosing my audio books, but am never sure until I try it. Generally, accents and local dialects are a plus for audio and this is easily evaluated by listening to a sample. Structure matters and is harder to know in advance. I think the less literary (whatever that means) and more linear the story, the better for audio. I find myself starting in print and switching to audio for lots of book club books. This is usually because I'm not so interested in the book, but want to join in the discussion. Since I listen while doing other things, I resent spending time wit…

Like
Hardcover Hearts
Hardcover Hearts
Feb 19, 2021
Replying to

As usual, Judy, we are in complete agreement. More straightforward narratives are easier to follow on audio. I tend to like mysteries, memoirs, history or other kinds of non-fiction in audio format. But you nailed it in that you never really know until you’ve made that initial time investment.

Like

Karen Wright
Karen Wright
Feb 17, 2021

Hi Sarah. So happy to see you’re back to blogging. I had a very similar experience with These Ghosts Are Family. I listened to the audio and enjoyed it but knew that it’s the kind of book I would’ve gotten more from if I’d read the print. That’s why I am retreading it this month with the book club. Format matters!

Like
Hardcover Hearts
Hardcover Hearts
Feb 17, 2021
Replying to

Thank you, Karen for that confirmation! I’ll look forward to hearing if form did make a difference in your second read.

Like

leo.delescen
Feb 17, 2021

How interesting, Sarah, to read your thoughts on formats. I feel very strongly about this and I can see why the audio format might have gotten in tue way of fully enjoying and appreciating this novel. The question is how to chose the appropriate format. Could you have known about the importance of the family tree in this book for example? I guess it is a hit and miss sometimes. Speaking about formats, this blog makes me see how it supplements your BookTube channel and has added value. A post such as this gives the opportunity to go more into detail and explain certain things more clearly. Interesting!

Like
Hardcover Hearts
Hardcover Hearts
Feb 17, 2021
Replying to

Why thank you, my friend! If I were a normal person, like you, as an example, and would research a bit more about the book before jumping in, I could have expected the timeline and being a potential challenge. I will have to consider that in the future. Excellent point. And thank you so much for the kind words.

Like
bottom of page